I'll do graphics last cause it's a big one
Style: I <3 KB games
Sound: It was fitting, but I think if you are going to make a full version of a kb game to still try to keep filesize below .5 mb, not 3.7 mb
Violence: Blades and stuf but the blood was crap (see below)
Interactivity: It's a game, it deserves no less than 10
Humor: What he said was funny, "Homophobia is gay" *cough inglor cough*
Graphics: This is a big one. I understand It's an API game and all, but you could pre-draw some graphics for the full version. Maby try to get the hobbit to look more symmetrical. But the big thing is animation. You said on the bbs (if i remember correctly) that animating via API would be very complicated. Her's how I would do it. Draw every frame of the animation in API in a seperate MC, and put all those MC's in an MC (i hope you know how to do this). Then simply change the _visiblity of all the mc's to false except the one being displayed. It should be simple really. If you need any more help with this contact KingGoboWoboFaun via AIM.
Overall: 8 add animation and I'll give it a 10.